My Favorite DIY cocktail ingredients so far

I have a weekly column on Serious Eats where I post recipes for DIY cocktail ingredients. That’s a lot of homemade cocktail ingredients! While I like all the recipes I post there, I do have my favorites. So if you have a hankerin’ to do a cocktail project but aren’t sure where to start, these are my favorite recipes I’ve done there so far:

Ginger Liqueur ~ While I love ginger liqueur, I was surprised that this ended up being one of my favorite and most useful homemade ingredients. It turns out I wasn’t alone, and I’ve been hearing from readers that they also fell in love with the slight kick and light sweetness of ginger liqueur.

Orange Bitters ~ Even though you only use a few drops at a time, bitters are a critical part of making cocktails. These orange bitters are different than what’s on the market while still performing reliably in cocktails. DIY bitters have a reputation as being a project for cocktail geeks only, but they’re actually not difficult to make. You’ll need to get a hold of some special tree bark and other things I had to go to the hippie store in Berkeley to find, but the result is something you can keep around for years.

Grenadine ~Real grenadine is radically different from the weird dyed-red goo you usually see in stores. For one thing, homemade grenadine actually tastes like it was made with pomegranates. It has a bright, tart flavor that goes well in everything from Tiki cocktails to light summer sparkling drinks. Also, if you make this, you just might be surprised to discover that you actually like Shirley Temples after all.

Allspice Dram ~ Spice is somewhat rare in your typical cocktail, which is why I love this allspice liqueur. It’s most known as a Tiki ingredient, but once you start experimenting with it, you’ll see it’s at home in a whole variety of concoctions.

Homemade Gin ~ Without going through the whole trouble (and possible illegality) of distilling your own spirits, you can still make a gin that’s darn good. And you can control the flavor profile: Maybe you want intense juniper with bold coriander notes? Or light floral and citrus flavors with a strong grassy finish? It’s up to you. Though, it’s basically gin-flavored vodka, it’s a totally legit way of making gin … many companies do a more fancified version of this process to make their product.

Hapatini

Liam Boylan takes great photos of the cocktails and creations featured in my DIY vs. Buy column. But he actually knows a hell of a lot about liquor and cocktails himself, so I asked him to share one of the drinks he devised.

Like Liam, the Hapatini is part Irish and part Japanese. It’s a good drink for people who love Martini-style cocktails. (And, when I say Martini, I mean drinks that are liquor plus another lower-alcohol-but-still-alcoholic ingredient. I do not mean things like Chocolate Martinis or Appletinis.)

Potcheen is basically Irish white whiskey (often called moonshine). He’s tried a lot of potcheen, so you don’t have to, and says Bunratty‘s sweet and slightly fruity taste make it the best choice for mixing. He used the orange bitters I made, but you could also go with your favorite brand.

Hapatini

2 ounces Bunratty potcheen

1/2 ounce nigori sake

2 dashes orange bitters

lemon twist

Pour liquid ingredients into a mixing glass filled with ice. Stir well and then strain into a chilled cocktail glass. Twist the piece of lemon over the top of the drink, then use as a garnish.

Photo by Liam Boylan, naturally

American Dad

This drink uses the ratio for a Manhattan as inspiration. Starting with rye, just like a Manhattan, this drink then uses a combination of Amer, dry vermouth, and maraschino liqueur instead of sweet vermouth. And of course where would we be without our good friend bitters? (You can use a homemade orange bitters if you’re feeling totally DIY.)

American Dad

2 ounces rye whiskey
1/2 ounce amer
1/4 ounce dry vermouth
1/4 ounce maraschino liqueur
1 dash orange bitters

Stir with ice and strain into chilled cocktail glass. Garnish with orange twist.

I used a ratio to create this drink. (Two parts strong + 1 part aromatic) Want to learn how to create your own drinks this way? Buy DIY Cocktails!

DIY vs. Buy: Legit Orange Bitters

This column was a fun excuse to make bitters the authentic way--with obscure bittering ingredients like gentian root and quassia chips. In my book, I have two great bitters recipes using easy-to-find grocery store items. They do the job and do it well. But the cocktail geek in me was happy to play around with weird tree bark for an traditional yet still totally original hardcore bitters recipe. (Don't worry: It isn't hard or expensive.)

Even though you only use a dash or two at a time, bitters can make or break a cocktail. Angostura bitters is the default, but orange bitters are actually very versatile.

Orange bitters are basically my cocktail Superman. When I've screwed up a drink by making it too sweet or gotten so close to perfection only to end up with something flat-tasting, orange bitters have swooped in to save the day. Just a drop or two can add the right depth or bridge together ingredients that aren't quite living up to their mixological potential. But orange bitters are so much more than a way to fix a bad drink—they're an essential part of so many balanced cocktails because of their deep, citrusy, spicy, and complex flavor.

DIY vs. Buy: Should I Make My Own Orange Bitters? on Serious Eats

Photo by Liam Boylan